Thursday 19 January 2017

No Offense to Raines, Pudge and Bagwell, but Class of '17 Falls Short


                First of all, congratulations to the Hall of Fame Class of 2017: Jeff Bagwell, Ivan Rodriguez and Tim Raines. If you were following my blog last July, you will remember I had a Top Five list of players who weren’t in the Hall but should be, and Raines was on that list. It’s so good to see him finally get the nod, as he was a player who was more than worthy and should have been in long ago.
                But that brings me to the four on the list who still are not in. I won’t bother griping about Joe Jackson and Pete Rose, because they were linked to gambling and as far as MLB is concerned, that’s worse than high treason for some reason.
                No, we’ll look at the other two. The Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA) can’t seem to find the courage to give Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens the necessary votes to gain entry to baseball’s hallowed ground. Since their playing days ended, both Clemens and Bonds have been accused of using Performance Enhancing Drugs and that seems to be the albatross that is draped around both of their necks.
                But this is where the hypocrisy of the BBWAA (and the Hall itself for that matter) is painfully obvious.
Here’s why: On December 4 of 2016, former baseball commissioner Bud Selig was selected for induction and will be included in the Class of 2017.
                Now, whether Bonds or Clemens actually used PEDs will forever be up for debate as there is no proof of the allegations. But to ignore that the “Steroid Era” happened under the watch of good ol’ Bud, and the fact that he turned a blind eye to it for so many years, and only introduced drug testing after the United States Congress got involved, and induct him into the Hall while refusing entry to perhaps the two biggest stars of the last 50 years, is an insult and a slap to the face of baseball fans.
                Consider Bonds and Clemens wouldn’t even have to face accusations if Selig had done his job and investigated alleged PED use like he should have, rather than pretend everything was on the up-and-up while watching all the money rolling into MLB. He didn’t dare mess with success, such as the McGwire and Sosa power display in the late 1990s that defied logic.
                But, the BBWAA won’t ask questions about Selig’s ineptitude when it comes to the PED situation, for fear of losing their precious spot in “the club” (so to speak) if they stopped towing the company line. So, instead they will keep printing stories about the players who cheated, rather than lay the blame at the feet of where it belongs: the former commissioner.
                And while it will be great to see Bagwell, Pudge and Raines enter the Hall this summer, it will be embarrassing watching them share the stage with Bud.

Follow us on Twitter at @topofthethird
Like us on Facebook
Send Feedback to topofthethird@gmail.com

Wednesday 18 January 2017

The Good (sort of), The Bad and the Ugly of the Jose Bautista Signing



                On Tuesday, the Toronto Blue Jays agreed to a one-year deal with outfielder Jose Bautista. The deal is worth $18 million for the 2017 season with mutual options for 2018 and 2019. While the Jays’ outfield was looking a little thin with Spring Training just over six weeks away, Bautista patrolling right field in 2017 wasn’t the option I had in mind when the 2016 season ended. However, he will have to do as it seems Blue Jays’ management (particularly Rogers) wasn’t keen on seriously pursuing other options.
                But let’s have a look at the good, the bad and the ugly of bringing Jose back to Toronto for at least one more season.
               
THE GOOD—As I mentioned before, despite being 36 years of age and suffering through some injury problems in 2016, Bautista is an improvement as the Jays’ outfield was looking suspect with the projected starters being (from left field to right) Melvin Upton, Kevin Pillar and Ezequiel Carrera. While I think Carrera has lots of potential, as seen from his performance in September and October when he played every day, he may be a year or two away from reaching his peak potential. Pillar, as much as I love his hustle, is your typical number nine centre fielder: great defense, not much more than average at the plate. Upton? Yeah, do I really need to say anything? Just look at his stats since the trade that brought him to Toronto and you’ll see how pitiful he was. Bautista, immediately makes the outfield better (offensively, anyway) provided he can avoid the injury bug he was stricken with last season.

THE BAD—Unless your name is Barry Bonds, do you really think you’re going to improve athletically with age? Bautista had a rather rough 2016 and while a lot can be contributed to his injuries, the skills have started to erode. There’s no shame in it, it happens to every one. Ask A-Rod. But besides that, Bautista brings a lot of baggage with him, particularly his big mouth. His feuding with umpires needs to stop. His out-of-place comments to the press (“I only swing at strikes” comes to mind) doesn’t make him a very desirable person to have around. But, hey, if he hits 40 dingers and drives in 100, he can mouth off all he wants. That’s a big “if”.

THE UGLY—This part hasn’t happened yet, but with Rogers at the controls, it’s inevitable. It will happen when team president, Mark Shapiro, and general manager, Ross Atkins, champion the Bautista signing as the key transaction of the off-season. Since the end of the season, there have been rumours afloat of how the Jays were actively pursing Dexter Fowler, Andrew McCutcheon, Jay Bruce, Charlie Blackmon or Curtis Granderson. No signings or trades ever happened because the Jays were NOT actively pursuing those players. Heck, they weren’t even pursuing Edwin Encarnacion. But somehow, those in charge will shrug their shoulders and say how they were outbid by other teams for those players, but don’t worry, the Bautista signing will be the one that leads to the World Series. It’s the spin Rogers likes to put on negative situations. Remember the Yu Darvish fiasco? Or the false reports about making serious offers to Prince Fielder? Unfortunately, it’s what you get with this ownership group. It’s been painfully obvious to Blue Jays’ supporters since they took over the club 17 years ago.
                But perhaps I’m being a bit too critical. Perhaps the Bautista signing will open the floodgates to other trades and signings to help build on the success of the past two seasons. One can only hope.

Follow us on Twitter at @topofthethird
Like us on Facebook
Send Feedback to topofthethird@gmail.com